William Haig

Do you agree with the view that, as far as strategy and tactics were concerned, Haig and his generals were pretty good? Use sources 6 and 7 and your own knowledge. Sir Douglas Haig was regarded as one of the most squ atomic number 18 generals during the First homo War. He faced a exit of problems that were difficult to overcome, but his strategies and tactics helped him to get through them, and in short enough he created the most sophisticated and massive triggerman corps that was to crack the German lines. Despite Haigs successes, he had a fair bit of opposition against him. rootage 6 is a firsthand diary extract from Corporal W H Shaw, who is recalling his experiences at the Battle of the Somme. This source is strongly against Haig and his routine of tactics. We be told that soldiers were being mown down and that the heavy munition was making no impact on the Germans at all, that they werent getting anywhere near them. Because this soldier was an eye witness, he ha s a firsthand reference to what happened during the war. Therefore, his (and other soldiers) experiences were very primary(prenominal) when determining whether or not Haigs tactics were successful. However, this measure was taken from the pre-war bombardment, which was deemed as a failure.

Therefore, the rest of the war isnt spoken of in this source, which was ultimately a success and Haigs tactics and strategies were key in this victory. In conjunction with this, thither is no hindsight in this source, thus limiting the information that we are given. Moreover, Corporal Shaw could have simply taken a detest to Haig, and would then try and dramatize the events that occurred during the battle. In comparison, starting time 7 is! a lot more on Haigs side. This Source is taken from a textbook about the First valet War. Straight away, we are told that Haig and his generals were pretty good, although they werent the grand team that has come out of the British Army, they still had a number of positives. We are told that...If you want to get a rise phase of the moon essay, order it on our website: OrderEssay.net

If you want to get a full information about our service, visit our page: write my essay